Sunday, August 31, 2014

On Sharing Musical Progress

I've noticed that, as a general rule, programmers are really good at sharing and talking about progress made in their work. Artists are fairly good at this as well. But musicians? We are really, really, really bad at it.

(Warning: navel gazing ahead!)
My guess is that musicians are generally trained to perform rather than create - the goal is to become capable of repeating something perfectly and on the spot. So while the journey there is interesting to ourselves, it's also not something we want to share with the world at large. It's a shadow of what we're trying to do. So we shy away from showing "unfinished" things. We don't want people to think that's the extent of our abilities.

Composers, though, do have a progress bar of sorts. There are things we can show that eventually add up to a greater whole. Maybe because most composers start as performers, we still have those weird feelings about sharing. Maybe because we so rarely work in teams, we're not accustomed to communicating with anyone about what we're doing. Also in play is an institutionalized fear that non-musicians can't understand the meaning of a work-in-progress and will judge something unfinished without understanding what to look for. While that's got some validity, it's also very self-perpetuating. If sharing music-in-progress were a common thing, people would have a better sense of how to approach understanding an unfinished piece.

(Okay, it's safe now, you can come back)
Point of this is, I would like to get better at sharing things in progress and make more contributions to this blog. I've been working on the second concept piece for a while now, but I don't really know what is interesting to other people. Whether or not anyone wants to read posts from me about all the weird little things I encounter is not something I have any sense of.

So... what do you want to know? What would be useful? What interests you?

Tuesday, August 12, 2014

Pillars of Character Progression

In order for our characters to be "varied and interesting," we need to add texture to them, ideally over the course of the game so that the player is invested in that story. Right now I envision five major pillars of character progression: Age, Training, Relationships, Consequences, Gear.

One of the next steps is for me to model these in a Lab, to prototype the way that they all play together to create the stats and aspects that drive combat, and the way they create interesting stories, explicitly or implicitly.

Age - our concept here is still that Warriors peak early, Hunters peak in middle age, and Mystics peak in old age. So we need age to affect stats and, ideally, art as well, in order to show that progression. Age also leads for many characters to an eventual retirement, which we'd like to feel like a well earned reward for the character. That means it likely needs to feel like a reward for the player as well.

Training - this is still a bit vague in the absence of a strong class design spec, but the general gist is that more experienced heroes are better at doing their jobs. This is intended to be most important for Mystics and Hunters, and less so for Warriors. Will we have class levels? Unclear.

Relationships - I think there's a lot of opportunity to break new ground here. Interesting characters are interested characters; they are interested in the world around them, in their fellow adventurers, in their foes, in art and music, architecture and family, and their ancestors. This stuff doesn't need to be terribly relevant to combat, where I see it integrated is in motivations, and the flavor around the character. A hobby becomes a family crest, a close friendship leads to a quest of vengeance, an obsession becomes a downfall, becomes a sidequest for redemption.

Consequences - We've been picking on this a bit with the recent stories. Your characters should change as a consequence of the missions they are on. This is thorny! It can't be too predictable, or it cries out for metagaming, and there needs to be a mix of good and bad. Maiming, blindness, etc. are excellent opportunities for research and quests. Curses, acquired powers, prosthetics, and animal companions become character-defining traits.

Lastly gear - I always found it interesting that games and stories handle gear very differently. In a story it's not uncommon to finish a quest with the same sword you started with. It's hard to name a game where this is true. It's likewise hard to name a work of fiction where the characters are constantly upgrading and swapping out equipment. I'd love for characters in Legacy to acquire character-defining pieces of gear that stick with them for the rest of their careers. We have a couple ideas for how to make that happen. At the core is the idea that their is only 1 "good" tier of gear. Once you have something at this level, it's to your advantage to keep it and upgrade it rather than swapping it out. That leads to two ideas, "training" bonuses with your favored gear, and upgrading the gear itself with various trophies* from missions. "That dragon skull would look GREAT on my pauldron!" And one other concept... characters should stop seeking new gear at a certain point in their career, and instead focus on optimizing what they have. This leaves the juicy, character-defining gear to the younger generation, who will have more time to be defined by it, and it prevents confusion about "is that Big Hammer Jim, or Dragon Armor Jim?" If he got the hammer first, that might just be enough for Jim. Let Lisa take the Dragon Armor.

So OK character progression. That's the next puzzle I think.. Can we generate a lot of characters that meet our "interesting" bar? We really, really want to get to a place where we have a ragtag troupe of unique professional adventurers, rather than a bunch of soldiers with standard issue chain mail.

*monsterparts.

Wizard doing something wizardy.


Do you think I drew too many doodlies on his robe? I think I drew too many.

Monday, August 11, 2014

Heroic Death

I'm knocked to the stone floor of the cavern by the clacking claws. My bow is broken, so is my leg, and my shoulder is torn. I'd really prefer to just lay down and wait -- the creature is already beginning to turn away from me,  I could crawl away, they could....rebind me... but I see its attention now on Nia and Tilbert, who are backing the other Thrixl into the fire in a desperate deadly dance.

Their backs are exposed. And honestly I never really wanted to go through rebinding. I don't think my mother would have approved of it.

I sigh and lash out with my good leg, sweeping the spindly chitinous legs of my foe on the smooth floor, and forcing its eyes back to me. With my good hand I grab my last remaining weapon. I always keep my whittling knife sharp. Sharper than my arrowheads, sometimes. Ha.

One chance, as it stoops over me. I flop my bad left arm right onto it's face, and it grabs the bait hard. I almost lost it right then, from the pain. But I always liked Tilbert. Nia's a decent girl too. left shoulder pull down, right arm thrust up, up through its neck with my knife. A good stroke.

Then it thrashes my arm off in its death spasm. That ought to hurt, I think, but I just lay my head down so I can watch Nia and Tillbert chop and burn, chop and burn. They look pretty good together. My vision fades as they finish and turn, because I don't want to see their faces when they see my body.

Not the way I expected to go, but I'm proud all the same. Shows ol' Luric. And the mission's done. I can hear them singing my song now, back in the hall. A proper hero.

~

Out of Character: death is something we want to be present in Legacy. Here it's offered as a choice: you can flop, feign death, and take a curse or consequence, (rebinding, maiming, etc.), or, you can take a heroic death and accomplish one more thing. In this case, a counter-attack on the monster that slew you. Mechanically that can be advantageous because you lose one guy to preserve two others. In this case the two remaining heroes would likely face additional injuries or deaths if surrounded by the remaining Thrixl. Making death feel heroic, and not just like a punishment is the goal.

Zinylle

(See this post for story.)

The idea is that I illustrate these as a way of forcing myself to do character concepts, which in turn will help guide the art style for the next pass on character art. Will it help? Only time will tell. These are obviously a different style than the current characters, different proportions, etc.

Sunday, August 10, 2014

The Eyes of Zinylle

Zinylle was a promising warrior. On her third battle, she was splashed in the face with the acidic venom of a Thrixl, and blinded. Even blind, she hacked the beast apart with white hot fury until it twitched no more. But her eyes were ruined permanently.

For two years she lingered, sad. She gave up her training, tending instead to what duties she could. Then a rare opportunity arose when her close friend Onriel was researching Thrixl origins and the nature of sight. Onriel proposed a dangerous course of action, and Zinylle accepted it. Onriel located two large gems, rubies. Such things were more common in those days, they say. She cut them to match the shape of the Thrixl eyes she had been studying, and imbued them with spells and rituals.

The operation to replace Zinylle's eyes was rough and bloody, and she nearly died of infection in the weeks after. Two moons later the result was revealed.

Zinylle did not regain her sight, exactly. She could see the vague shadows of terrain and friendly figures, just enough to move around and get her job done without having to feel for things. But when a rabid dog raced into the stone yard, she grabbed a nearby sword, raced toward it and slew it in one stroke before it could reach the confused masons. Foes, it turned out, shone out to Zinylle in fiery red, coruscant, in every florid detail.

She returned to the battlefield, always volunteering for those missions where her disadvantage would be an advantage: deep forests, twisted labyrinths, lurking hunters. She had an incredibly successful career hunting the sort of nightmares that others refuse to face.


Of course, she would have been buried with her eyes, and we do not know the exact location. But at the end of the account of Zinylle, which appears to be written by Onriel, the author describes how the two friends wished that the eyes could help others as well. So you see Jacon, your situation is not without hope. If you are willing, continue your training. Keep your body strong. I will search for the tomb.

Saturday, August 9, 2014

Elmnic Wolfhue


Get like half a dozen more of these guys together and they'll summon Captain Planet.

PS- In case anyone cares about this kind of thing, my sketches are dirty as dirt. I think some people sketch "cleanly." I do not. If I know I'm going into Illustrator anyway, I do all the fiddly movement in there.





Steelhorns is that you?


In what would normally have been his later years, old Korsvo spent a lot of time alone, researching his own topics.  He rarely ventured out of the fortress, but he did continue to make breakthroughs in ritual magic, which he passed on to the company with detailed illustrations and instructions. He was a favorite instructor and mentor for many of the younger mystics, and he loved to lecture on blood theory and ley lines if he got too much wine in him.

One day word came in of a rampaging minotaur to the east. When the company called for volunteers, Korsvo tossed his aged silver amulet onto the table before anyone else. Some of the company members were surprised, but then, it's was not uncommon for an old veteran to carry an old grudge that he would not discuss. The second token on the table belonged to Havstad, Master of Traps. He was known to have quested with Korsvo, many years ago.

Young Lianna placed her amulet on the table third, and she brought back this account of the battle:
Havstad led us through the forest for a long time, and instead of confronting the beast directly, we set up an intricate line of baits and traps, to corral the creature to the back of a specific canyon, near the mouth of a shallow cave.
With the beast cornered, we were to approach, I was to take the lead as the Shield Arm. Well that was the plan. What happened instead was that once Havstad has finished trapping the escape route, Korsvo rushed in, shouting wildly. I leapt to try to keep up but Havstad motioned me back and took up an arrow and trained his sights on the beast.
I ran forward in spite of the warning and this is what I saw. Korsvo leapt directly in front of the beast, throwing rocks and insults as fast as he could. The beast raised its great spiked club and brought it down on frail Korsvo's skull. His whole frame was slammed to the ground, head split open. I was horrified. And then it happened. Korsvo's blood rushed out of his body and swirled in a hideous whirlpool around the enraged and suddenly terrified beast. I held my charge for a split second then. It seemed prudent.
I was aware of Havdar shouting out "hold! hold!" behind me, and it seemed to me I was out of my depth. I held. The blood subsided and the minotaur slumped forward to the ground, and then, dropping its weapon, stood again unsteadily. It flexed its arms and stretched its legs and let out what I would have to describe as a chuckle. It bowed to me, and to Havstad, three times. Havstad lowered his aim and said "quest accomplished."
The beast calmly unthreaded old Korsvo's amulet from his broken body and attemped to wear it. This did not work due to the horns being in the way, which was oddly comical. Clutching the amulet instead, he walked out of the canyon, expertly avoiding our traps. We buried Korsvo's remains at the site, but we did not mourn.
For some years afterwards, at times, a jolly minotaur would rush into the middle of a woodland battle as if from nowhere, a silver amulet of the company hanging from his burly neck. He'd smash some foes and give a great bovine laugh and be off again, just as quick. Old Korsvo usually got the credit. Also for years afterwards, at times, farmers would complain that someone or something was visiting their cow pastures at night. Old Korsvo usually got the blame.

Curses

Elmnic Wolfhue of Ogergin's Crossing faces down the last beast, as his comrades circle behind it. Suddenly it lunges, and its jaws tear at his arm, and then at his torso. He cries out and collapses to the forest floor. In that instant his friends rush in to finish it off, with spear and fire. Elmnic lays on the stones and branches, breathing raggedly and bleeding. Not much time.

Hadyel fishes through her pack while Jud carries Elmnic to a flat spot and lies him down. Jud begins to scribe a circle in the dirt with his spear point, all around Elmnic. Hadyel returns and grimly offers the dying hunter a leather flask. Their eyes meet for a long moment. Elmnic considers his choice. In the end his burning hatred for our accursed foes makes his choice for him. He takes the flask with his left hand and drinks the contents. Jud and Hadyel finish the circle to the best of their knowledge and abilities.

Blood of the enemy, blood of the comrade, blood of the land. Elmnic screams and contorts. His wounds stop bleeding red, instead a thick yellow sap oozes from them. His mauled right arm twists and writhes, and the two hold him down to the ground while the magic takes its course. Then they bind his body and his bulging and discolored right arm with linen, and fashion a sled for him that the ponies can pull. He'll be asleep for weeks, if he's lucky. Then he may wake up.

~

Heroes Remembered, volume 4

Elmnic Oakhand was one of the most feared and respected hunters for miles. In his 24th summer he was mortally wounded by a magical beast in the forest, and underwent the ritual of rebinding on a makeshift altar. (see footnote) His right arm was transformed into a knotted, woodish bludgeon, in the vague shape of an arm and fist. He retained sense and control, although its range of motion was limited. In addition, ever after he bled a thick yellow sap, rather than blood.

He returned to his patrol almost immediately after regaining consciousness. Unable to aim a bow because of the ritual, he nevertheless was an uncanny tracker and trapper, and in time developed a close combat style that took full advantage of his unique physiology. In the course of his later career he slew two dozen of the foul hounds that ripped his body apart. Interestingly, his two daughters were born with grass-green hair. They lived full and happy lives.

footnote: This is the earliest account of a successful rebinding on the battlefield, a practice that has since become more common and successful, though the results remain highly unpredictable. It is thought that the three bloods influence the outcome, but exactly how remains unclear.